Ok, I saw it on Saturday night. I liked the one with Thomas Jane better. This one had a bunch of action and gore. You never really feel empathetic for this punisher. The movie does not draw you into the character. They didn't go into enough detail of why he is the punisher. It's basically just some bad ass that goes around killing everybody. It had some cool parts but overall I was not impressed. Contrary to what critics and others think, I really liked the one with Jane and Travolta. I read that Jane did not do this punisher because he didn't like the direction that they took the character. I agree with him. Very dissapointing.