A little background: I dated this Girl #1 for about a month in high school, so it wasn't anything really serious (this was about 8 years ago). Then, I ran into her about 2 weeks ago at a club, and we talked, I got her number, etc. Girl #2 is another girl that I'm talking to that I met at a party my cousin had about a week ago. So I made plans to go out with Girl #1 Saturday night. My cousin's friend was having a party, so we went and ate dinner and then went and met my cousin at this party. Before we made the plans, I was kind of worried that Girl #2 would be there since she is friends with my cousin and that's how I met her, so I asked him ahead of time, and he said she wouldn't be there. While we were at the party, my cousin was talking to some of his other friends, and the were going out, so we decided to go with them. Yeah, I should have known. We got to the club, and who shows up? Girl #2. Oops. It was kind of awkward, but at least Girl #1 didn't know what was going on. I laughed a few times about it, but she had no idea what I was laughing about, and I played it off. lol Luckily Girl #2 didn't do anything psycho or make a scene or anything like that, but I'm not really sure exactly what to do now. I still want to go out with her some time, but it's kind of weird that she saw me out on a date with another girl. I think I'm just going to call her tomorrow and explain the situation to her and tell her that I still want to go out some time. You know, this was the first time I've been out with Girl #1, I didn't know she was going to be there, etc., but that I still want to go out with her some time. I've never really been in a situation like this before, so I'm not really sure how to handle it. And even funnier is that I'm dating/talking to 4 girls right now. This is ridiculous...I don't know how people can do this. It's way too much work and too confusing...I need to hurry up and narrow this down quick. What would you do?